top of page

Were there more than two criminals?

wts07073
Mar 31, 2017
2 min read

Matthew 27 38 Then were there two thieves crucified with him, one on the right hand, and another on the left.  -kjv Matthew 27 44 The thieves also, which were crucified with him, cast the same in his teeth.  -kjv Question from moody radio listener on Mar 25, 2017 on openline: Could you help me understand regards to the passages that referred to the criminals who were crucified with Jesus? Matthew, Mark implied that multiple criminals taunted Jesus. In Luke's account, one of the criminals acknowledged who Jesus was and rebuked the other one. Could there have been more than just two? Normally, we just assumed there have been three of them, two criminals, one who believed and one who did not and Jesus in the middle. Could there have been more criminals crucified who would have been taunting Jesus? Answer from Dr Michael Rydelnik and his wife Eva Rydelnik. Dr Michael Rydelnik: I don't think there were just Jesus and the two criminals there. When the Romans executed people, they did a whole bunch. Probably there were more people taunting Jesus than just the two there. It appears that what you have in Luke is one of those who were there being crucified with the Lord Jesus, he's the one who repents and that's the one whom Jesus says "this day you will be with me in Paradise" and there's probably a wide street where many people were being crucified for a variety of reasons. The word that is used here for thiefs is better rebels, these were probably ... Eva Rydelnik: They were zealots against Rome. They were political activist against Rome, which is why one of the charges against Jesus which led to him being crucified was ... Dr Michael Rydelnik : The king of the Jews trying to bring down the Romans. Eva Rydelnik: They use a political accusation against him. Dr Michael Rydelnik: So they were people who were involved in revolt against Rome. Eva Rydelnik: In Matthew 27:44, it just say the robbers who were crucified with him were insulting him but it doesn't say they were dissidents. In verse 38, it says at that time, two robbers were crucified with him. One on the right, one on the left, so in verse 38, it says there were two, in verse 44, it says the robbers. The fact that there were two does not limit that there was only two.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Now is the Time of Salvation by J.C.Ryle

Whatever a person sows—that they shall also reap! Whatever we love in time—we shall love in eternity! Whatever we think wearisome now—we shall think wearisome then. You must be born again—or heaven it

 
 
 
Those who overcome ...

Open Line on 13 June 2026 Hour 2 @9:05 Listener: In Revelations 2:26, in the message Thyatira, it says to him who overcome and keeps my deeds until the end, I would give authority over the nations. So

 
 
 
In Need of a New Heart by J.C.Ryle

Life is the mightiest of all possessions. From death to life is the mightiest of all changes. And no change short of this will ever avail to fit a person’s soul for heaven. It is not a little mending

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page